Brandon Aubrey Flat Out Rejects the Dallas Cowboys – Despite an Offer That Would Have Made Him the Highest-Paid Kicker in the NFL – Because He Wants Even More
Dallas, Texas
One of the most surprising storylines of the Dallas Cowboys’ 2026 offseason isn’t centered on a quarterback or star wide receiver.
It’s coming from special teams.
According to multiple sources close to the situation, Brandon Aubrey has declined a contract extension from the Dallas Cowboys — even though the deal reportedly would have made him the highest-paid kicker in the NFL.

This was no routine offer.
Dallas is believed to have presented a package that would surpass every other kicker’s annual salary, signaling just how valuable Aubrey has become to the franchise. Since arriving in Dallas, he has established himself as one of the most reliable kickers in the league, delivering in high-pressure moments and showing rare consistency from long distance.
Still, Aubrey said no.
The reason appears straightforward: he believes his market value exceeds even that record-setting offer. After back-to-back elite seasons, Aubrey and his representation are reportedly seeking a deal that pushes the financial ceiling even higher — not only in average annual value but also in guaranteed money.
In today’s NFL, the importance of a dependable kicker cannot be overstated. Close games are often decided by a single possession, and a consistent leg can swing playoff races. Around the league, several teams are believed to be closely monitoring the situation.

For the Cowboys, the decision is complicated.
The franchise has already committed significant financial resources to its offensive line and defensive core while attempting to recalibrate after consecutive disappointing seasons. Allocating additional cap space to a kicker — even one of Aubrey’s caliber — requires careful long-term planning.
But letting him walk would carry risk.
In modern NFL football, championships can hinge on one kick. And Aubrey has repeatedly demonstrated he can deliver when it matters most.
Negotiations are expected to continue, but Aubrey’s refusal of a league-topping offer sends a clear message: he views himself as more than just the best-paid kicker — he wants to reset the market entirely.
Now the Cowboys must decide whether to meet that demand or risk watching one of the league’s most dependable weapons test free agency.













