Brandon Aubrey Flat Out Rejects the Dallas Cowboys – Despite an Offer That Would Have Made Him the Highest-Paid Kicker in the NFL – Because He Wants Even More

DeMarvion Overshown, one of the Dallas Cowboys’ most promising young talents, is facing the harshest reality of his young career. Selected in the third round of the 2023 NFL Draft (pick 90 overall), Overshown signed a four-year rookie contract worth approximately $5.39 million, including a signing bonus of around $920,000 and equivalent guaranteed money. The deal runs through the end of the 2026 season, meaning 2026 is his final year under contract with the Cowboys. Without a new agreement, Overshown will become an unrestricted free agent in 2027. However, the Cowboys have made their stance clear and pragmatic: no early contract extension, no exercise of any fifth-year option (not applicable as he is a third-round pick), and no extension talks this offseason. Instead, the team is taking a strict “wait and see” approach - waiting to see if Overshown can finally play a full, healthy season. This is the Cowboys’ final decision regarding this young talent, driven by a brutal injury history that has derailed three out of the four years of his $5 million rookie deal. Overshown’s unfortunate injury history: 2023 (rookie year): Suffered a torn ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) in his left knee during the second preseason game (August 2023). Placed on injured reserve immediately and missed the entire regular season. 2024: Returned strong, playing in 13 games (12 starts), recording 90 tackles, 8 TFLs, 5 sacks, 1 pick-six, and several explosive plays. But in Week 14, he tore his ACL, MCL, and PCL in his right knee - a devastating multi-ligament injury. Underwent surgery shortly after and missed the rest of the season. 2025: Still recovering from the major 2024 knee surgery, he was placed on the PUP list during preseason. Missed the first 10-11 games (Weeks 1–10 or similar), returned around Week 11, and played in roughly 6 games with more modest production (around 28 tackles). Late in the season, he suffered a concussion and was ruled out for some final games. In total, Overshown has appeared in only about 19 games across three seasons (out of a possible 51), undergoing major surgery on both knees and dealing with additional setbacks. When healthy, he is an explosive, versatile linebacker with star potential—strong in run defense, pass rushing, and coverage. Yet the repeated injuries have turned him into a classic “what-if” story for the Cowboys. At the recent NFL Scouting Combine (February 2026), Cowboys COO Stephen Jones was blunt: “The biggest thing is that, availability... Certainly, no one wants to play the game more than him... But, obviously, he needs to put together a full season, and if he does, I think it’s going to be a great season... The only question mark he has is his injury issues he’s had and getting through a full year.” This decision reflects the Cowboys’ cold, business-like reality: they prioritize availability over potential. Even though Overshown enters the 2026 offseason fully healthy for the first time, and is expected to play a bigger role in the new base 3-4 defense under coordinator Christian Parker, 2026 will be his make-or-break year. If he stays healthy and performs at a high level throughout a full season, he could earn a big extension from Dallas or attract strong interest in free agency. If injuries persist, he may leave the Cowboys without being re-signed. For the Cowboys, it’s a sensible move given limited cap space and the need to build a competitive roster. For fans, it’s a heartbreaking outcome for “Agent Zero”—a young talent who once promised to transform the defense but has been repeatedly sidelined by injury throughout his $5 million rookie contract. Overshown’s future now rests entirely on his ability to stay on the field in this pivotal 2026 season.