Former Dallas Cowboys QB Slammed for Misleading Commentary in Bills vs. Broncos Divisional Round Game – CBS Officially Bans Him from Broadcasting, But Coach Mike McCarthy's Move Is What’s Shocking the Entire NFL

Denver, Colorado – January 22, 2026

The Divisional Round playoff clash between the Buffalo Bills and Denver Broncos wasn’t just a battle on the field—it became the epicenter of intense backlash aimed at CBS broadcaster Tony Romo. The legendary former Dallas Cowboys quarterback was brutally roasted by fans and media alike for a string of glaring errors and misleading analysis during the game.

Memorable lowlights included Romo accidentally calling Josh Allen (Bills QB) “Patrick Mahomes”—a jaw-dropping mix-up since Mahomes wasn’t even in the playoffs this year. He also botched a fake punt prediction, miscalled down-and-distance, and delivered awkward, drawn-out commentary that felt more confusing than insightful. Social media erupted, with fans labeling it a “disaster” and a “waste of airtime.” Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports led the charge, declaring Romo was “completely lost.”

In response, CBS Sports issued a firm decision: an official one-week suspension from the broadcast booth, sidelining Romo from upcoming playoff games (including the AFC Championship). An internal network source stated: “We are committed to the highest standards of accuracy and broadcast quality. The mistakes in such a high-stakes game directly impacted the viewer experience, and this is a necessary step to reinforce accountability.”

The one-week suspension sent shockwaves across the NFL, especially since Romo is still under a massive 10-year, $180 million contract (signed in 2020, running through 2030). Some called the penalty too lenient given the level of outrage, while others viewed it as a serious “wake-up call” to sharpen his game before returning. CBS confirmed Romo will be back after the week, but the forced break has already sparked heated debate about his future as lead analyst.

What truly stunned the league, however, was the unexpected move from Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy. In a rare public statement, McCarthy—who once worked closely with Romo during his playing days—delivered a powerful defense:

“That guy has spent his entire career delivering deep, accurate breakdowns that very few can match. He’s not perfect, but in the toughest moments, he always gives everything to help fans understand the game better. Don’t let a couple of small mistakes overshadow his real value—he deserves respect, not to be pushed off the stage over one off night.”

McCarthy’s strong words—a head coach with Super Bowl aspirations backing his old quarterback—came as a bombshell. It wasn’t just old friendship; it hinted at the possibility of Romo potentially transitioning to a coaching or advisory role with the Cowboys if broadcasting troubles continue. The entire NFL is buzzing: Is this a sign Romo could return to Dallas in a new capacity, or simply a heartfelt gesture between two Cowboys legends?

While CBS insists the one-week suspension is temporary, McCarthy’s defense has shifted the narrative—from piling on Romo to broader debates about fairness in NFL media. Will a week off be enough for Romo to regain his edge, or is this just the start of bigger drama ahead?