The New York Yankees issue an ultimatum to Cody Bellinger: either sign or get out while extending an invitation to the 2019 All-Star and 2025 Heart and Hustle Award winner as a potential replacement.

The New York Yankees are exploring backup options in case Cody Bellinger signs elsewhere during the 2026 offseason. While Bellinger remains their top priority, no deal has been finalized, leaving room for alternatives. Sources indicate Tommy Pham, a free-agent outfielder, is being considered to fill Bellinger’s role, potentially platooning with Jasson Domínguez or Spencer Jones.

Pham’s stats show he is a serviceable MLB player despite a controversial reputation. Last season with the Pittsburgh Pirates, he hit .245 with 10 home runs and 52 RBIs and has appeared in 37 career playoff games. His career OPS against left-handed pitching is .802, making him a viable platoon option alongside Domínguez.

Off the field, Pham has a history of contentious behavior. In a game against the Toronto Blue Jays, he flipped his bat after a walk and confronted catcher Tyler Heineman, leading to benches clearing. Pham later defended his actions on social media, arguing that Heineman’s comments questioning the umpire were disrespectful. This reputation for confrontation could make him a polarizing figure but may also fit the Yankees’ need for a scrappy, competitive outfielder.

Yankees insider Brendan Kuty of The Athletic highlighted Austin Hays as another possible option, noting his strong numbers against left-handed pitching last season and his ability to contribute in a platoon role. Pham would serve a similar function if Bellinger departs.

The Yankees have submitted a second offer to Bellinger, emphasizing their desire to retain him. According to reports, keeping Bellinger primarily in left field with Trent Grisham in center and Aaron Judge in right would allow the team to include Domínguez or Spencer Jones in potential trades or adjustments to the roster.

While Edward Cabrera was initially considered, he was eventually traded to the Chicago Cubs. The Yankees may still pursue other starting pitchers, but the team’s priority remains finalizing Bellinger’s contract before pursuing additional roster moves.

Overall, the Yankees are positioning themselves to maintain depth and competitiveness in the outfield while navigating the free-agent market, balancing the need for proven talent with strategic backups in case of departures.